You Can Be Profitable and Broke at the Same Time. In Restoration, It's the Default.

You can be profitable and broke at the same time. In restoration it is practically the default. Your P&L says the quarter was good. Your checking account says you are juggling payroll against a carrier check that has not shown up. Both statements are accurate, and the owner who treats them as a contradiction keeps getting surprised.

Two clocks, one business

The IRS puts the distinction plainly in Publication 538. Under the cash method, "you generally report income in the tax year you receive it, and deduct expenses in the tax year in which you pay the expenses." Under the accrual method, "you generally report income in the tax year you earn it, regardless of when payment is received. You deduct expenses in the tax year you incur them, regardless of when payment is made."

That is tax language, but it describes two clocks that every growing contractor ends up living on. Profit runs on the earning clock: work done, work billed. Cash runs on the paying clock: money in, money out. In a business where the work is done this week and the money arrives in six, the two clocks drift apart, and the gap is where companies get hurt.

This is not a study. It is an accounting fundamental, and the rest of this post is how I see it play out in restoration. Nothing below is a benchmark.

Where restoration pries the clocks apart

Four mechanics do most of the damage.

ACV and recoverable depreciation. On many property claims the carrier pays the actual cash value first and releases the depreciation holdback later, after the work is complete and documented. You booked the whole invoice as revenue. You collected part of it.

Supplements. Scope is discovered, not estimated. You open a wall, find more damage, and the supplement is real work done today with a payment decision weeks out. The cost hit your cash now. The revenue may not exist yet, even on paper.

Retainage. On reconstruction work billed to commercial customers or through a general contractor, a slice of every draw is held back until closeout. It is earned, it is on the P&L, and it is not in the bank.

Up-front costs. Crews, equipment, disposal and subcontractors are paid on your schedule, not the carrier's. You fund the job from day one.

A worked example (illustration, not data)

Say a water mitigation and repair job invoices at $50,000. You paid $38,000 in labor, materials and subs. On paper, you made $12,000. Now suppose that thirty days in, the carrier has paid $32,000 and is holding the rest pending completion paperwork.

Profit on paper is plus $12,000. Cash on this job is $32,000 collected minus $38,000 paid, which is minus $6,000. You are profitable and you are $6,000 out of pocket. Multiply that by every open job on the board in a busy month and you can see how a company with a great margin ends up calling its line of credit to cover payroll.

Four moves

1. Track net cash position per open job, not just margin. Cash collected minus cash spent, job by job. A negative number on a job that is still running means you are the bank for that customer.
2. Split your receivables by type. In QuickBooks Online, use separate items or a custom field to tag ACV, recoverable depreciation, supplements and retainage. A single "accounts receivable" balance hides the part you cannot collect yet.
3. Forecast cash on the paying clock. Build a 13-week cash forecast from expected receipt dates, not invoice dates. Put holdbacks and supplements on their own lines with a realistic release date.
4. Read the P&L and the cash forecast together. Margin tells you whether the work pays. The forecast tells you whether you can survive until it does. Neither one replaces the other.

If a job shows a healthy margin and a negative cash position for more than a few weeks, that is the signal to chase the paperwork, bill the next phase, or have a harder conversation about deposits. It is not a signal to hire another crew.

Where a CFO fits

Nothing here requires an advanced degree. It requires someone to build the job-level cash view, keep it current, and tell you what it means before payroll week. If that is a gap in your shop, that is what our fractional CFO subscription is for, and you can reach out here to talk through where your cash is actually stuck.

This article is for general education only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice for your situation. Talk with your own advisor before changing how you bill or report.

← Back to all posts